Degree Date

12-2026

Document Type

Dissertation - Public Access

Degree Name

Ed.D. Doctor of Education

Academic Discipline

Educational Leadership

First Advisor

Dr. Carla Sparks

Abstract

This program evaluation examined how educators and school leaders interpret and implement Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) and restorative discipline practices for students with disabilities in secondary settings, and what factors influence the equity and consistency of their application. Although secondary schools have widely adopted these frameworks to reduce exclusionary discipline, students with disabilities continue to be removed from instruction at disproportionate rates, revealing a gap between policy and practice. The overarching research question asked how educators interpret and implement these frameworks for students with disabilities, including alignment with behavioral intervention plans and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, and what shapes the equity and consistency of their application. The study used a qualitative-dominant mixed-methods design grounded in an implementation focused program evaluation approach, collecting data through a national educator survey (N = 35), five semi-structured interviews, and document analysis. Findings indicated that although the frameworks were widely adopted, they were unevenly enacted. PBIS was often reduced to rewards, and restorative practices were inconsistently understood and rarely implemented with fidelity. Discipline for students with disabilities depended more on individual judgment and bias than on shared policy, and educators identified inadequate training and limited guidance as central barriers, with equity suffering as a result. Taken together, the findings identify educator capacity and system design, rather than individual discretion, as the decisive levers for equitable discipline. Recommendations include sustained, job-embedded professional development, clear decision-making tools, distributed special education expertise, formative review of discipline data disaggregated by disability status, and a supporting policy to institutionalize these supports.

Share

COinS